Comparing many probability density functions

The philentropy package has several mechanisms to calculate distances between probability density functions. The main one is to use the the distance() function, which enables to compute 46 different distances/similarities between probability density functions (see ?philentropy::distance and a companion vignette for details). Alternatively, it is possible to call each distance/dissimilarity function directly. For example, the euclidean() function will compute the euclidean distance, while jaccard - the Jaccard distance. The complete list of available distance measures are available with the philentropy::getDistMethods() function.

Both of the above approaches have their pros and cons. The distance() function is more flexible as it allows users to use any distance measure and can return either a matrix or a dist object. It also has several defensive programming checks implemented, and thus, it is more appropriate for regular users. Single distance functions, such as euclidean() or jaccard(), can be, on the other hand, slightly faster as they directly call the underlining C++ code.

Now, we introduce three new low-level functions that are intermediaries between distance() and single distance functions. They are fairly flexible, allowing to use of any implemented distance measure, but also usually faster than calling the distance() functions (especially, if it is needed to use many times). These functions are:

dist_one_one() - expects two vectors (probability density functions), returns a single value
dist_one_many() - expects one vector (a probability density function) and one matrix (a set of probability density functions), returns a vector of values
dist_many_many() - expects two matrices (two sets of probability density functions), returns a matrix of values

Let’s start testing them by attaching the philentropy package.

library(philentropy)

`dist_one_one()`

dist_one_one() is a lower level equivalent to distance(). However, instead of accepting a numeric data.frame or matrix, it expects two vectors representing probability density functions. In this example, we create two vectors, P and Q.

P <- 1:10 / sum(1:10)
Q <- 20:29 / sum(20:29)

To calculate the euclidean distance between them we can use several approaches - (a) build-in R dist() function, (b) philentropy::distance(), (c) philentropy::euclidean(), or the new dist_one_one().

# install.packages("microbenchmark")
microbenchmark::microbenchmark(
  dist(rbind(P, Q), method = "euclidean"),
  distance(rbind(P, Q), method = "euclidean", test.na = FALSE, mute.message = TRUE),
  euclidean(P, Q, FALSE),
  dist_one_one(P, Q, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)
)

## Warning in microbenchmark::microbenchmark(dist(rbind(P, Q), method =
## "euclidean"), : less accurate nanosecond times to avoid potential integer
## overflows

## Unit: nanoseconds
##                                                                                    expr
##                                                 dist(rbind(P, Q), method = "euclidean")
##  distance(rbind(P, Q), method = "euclidean", test.na = FALSE,      mute.message = TRUE)
##                                                                  euclidean(P, Q, FALSE)
##                                dist_one_one(P, Q, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)
##   min   lq     mean  median      uq    max neval
##  5986 6396  8233.62  6724.0  7113.5 108691   100
##  9266 9922 18894.85 10475.5 11931.0 783756   100
##   820  902  1150.87   943.0  1086.5   3854   100
##  1189 1271  1756.03  1353.0  1496.5  19680   100

All of them return the same, single value. However, as you can see in the benchmark above, some are more flexible, and others are faster.

`dist_one_many()`

The role of dist_one_many() is to calculate distances between one probability density function (in a form of a vector) and a set of probability density functions (as rows in a matrix).

Firstly, let’s create our example data.

set.seed(2020-08-20)
P <- 1:10 / sum(1:10)
M <- t(replicate(100, sample(1:10, size = 10) / 55))

P is our input vector and M is our input matrix.

Distances between the P vector and probability density functions in M can be calculated using several approaches. For example, we could write a for loop (adding a new code) or just use the existing distance() function and extract only one row (or column) from the results. The dist_one_many() allows for this calculation directly as it goes through each row in M and calculates a given distance measure between P and values in this row.

# install.packages("microbenchmark")
microbenchmark::microbenchmark(
  as.matrix(dist(rbind(P, M), method = "euclidean"))[1, ][-1],
  distance(rbind(P, M), method = "euclidean", test.na = FALSE, mute.message = TRUE)[1, ][-1],
  dist_one_many(P, M, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)
)

## Unit: microseconds
##                                                                                             expr
##                                      as.matrix(dist(rbind(P, M), method = "euclidean"))[1, ][-1]
##  distance(rbind(P, M), method = "euclidean", test.na = FALSE,      mute.message = TRUE)[1, ][-1]
##                                        dist_one_many(P, M, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)
##       min        lq        mean     median        uq       max neval
##   130.831  148.1125   160.26367   157.9935   167.690   263.548   100
##  9016.515 9735.1630 11155.15536 10312.8735 12742.677 14336.511   100
##     9.512   10.3730    12.67269    11.8285    13.858    44.526   100

The dist_one_many() returns a vector of values. It is, in this case, much faster than distance(), and visibly faster than dist() while allowing for more possible distance measures to be used.

`dist_many_many()`

dist_many_many() calculates distances between two sets of probability density functions (as rows in two matrix objects).

Let’s create two new matrix example data.

set.seed(2020-08-20)
M1 <- t(replicate(10, sample(1:10, size = 10) / 55))
M2 <- t(replicate(10, sample(1:10, size = 10) / 55))

M1 is our first input matrix and M2 is our second input matrix. I am not aware of any function build-in R that allows calculating distances between rows of two matrices, and thus, to solve this problem, we can create our own - many_dists()…

many_dists = function(m1, m2){
  r = matrix(nrow = nrow(m1), ncol = nrow(m2))
  for (i in seq_len(nrow(m1))){
    for (j in seq_len(nrow(m2))){
      x = rbind(m1[i, ], m2[j, ])
      r[i, j] = distance(x, method = "euclidean", mute.message = TRUE)
    }
  }
  r
}

… and compare it to dist_many_many().

# install.packages("microbenchmark")
microbenchmark::microbenchmark(
  many_dists(M1, M2),
  dist_many_many(M1, M2, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)
)

## Unit: microseconds
##                                                          expr     min       lq
##                                            many_dists(M1, M2) 958.990 994.5575
##  dist_many_many(M1, M2, method = "euclidean", testNA = FALSE)  14.104  14.8830
##        mean   median       uq      max neval
##  1181.08126 1013.458 1081.375 4497.126   100
##    16.36269   15.375   16.851   37.843   100

Both many_dists()and dist_many_many() return a matrix. The above benchmark concludes that dist_many_many() is about 30 times faster than our custom many_dists() approach.

Jakub Nowosad

2021-08-20

`dist_one_one()`

`dist_one_many()`

`dist_many_many()`